Prospect System Ranking – 26th (Previous Rank - 30th)
GM: Lou Lamoriello Hired: June 2018
COACH: Patrick Roy Hired: January 2024
The New York Islanders are the 10th lowest scoring team among NHL teams across the last five seasons, and it does not take long to crack the code as to why. While their offensive talent gets by, there is an obvious lack of star-worthy goal scorers, which trickles throughout the system. Mathew Barzal leads the pack with 295 points throughout those five years, but if they are going to take that next step, they’ll need much more than that.
Enter Cole Eiserman, McKeen’s 71st-ranked prospect. Despite some concerns about his compete and skating levels, the Massachusetts native is one of the purest goal scorers among the 2024 Draft class. Eiserman’s talent is evident, as he holds two of the top three goal-scoring seasons in the history of the NTDP, with 62 and 58 goals, respectively. Expectations for those goals to translate to the higher levels are high, as the talent level takes a slight nosedive after him.
With their second pick in the 2024 Draft (65th overall), the Islanders added an intriguing defensive prospect in overager Jesse Pulkkinen (279th). Pulkkinen, who will continue his development overseas, brings a compelling combination of size (6-foot-6) and skill to the blue line, offering some hope for the future of the Islanders' defence.
Closer to home, William Dufour (143rd) has been a solid contributor at the AHL level but is still likely a season away from NHL consideration. Danny Nelson (150th) continues to develop at the collegiate level, and Calle Odelius (189th) is also a few years away from making an impact. Meanwhile, Ruslan Iskhakov, who showed significant promise in Bridgeport, has opted to return to the KHL, stalling any NHL potential he may have had. All that said, the shelves are bare for immediate youthful injection.
On a positive note, the Islanders successfully integrated Simon Holmstrom into the lineup on a full-time basis, and the 2024-25 season could see rearguard Samuel Bolduc leap full-time in the NHL.
For a team that has struggled to find a consistent identity, exemplified by scattered playoff appearances, it’s difficult to pinpoint where the organization stands. Barzal (27), Brock Nelson (32), Anders Lee (34), Noah Dobson (24), and Ilya Sorokin (29) remain the backbone of this club. However, with an aging core, the need for youthful reinforcements is becoming increasingly urgent—and as of today, that talent pool is scarce.
New York Islanders Top-15 Prospects
1. Cole Eiserman
Michael Dal Colle. Kieffer Bellows. Oliver Wahlstrom. The Islanders are desperately hoping that Eiserman can buck the trend of recently failed draft picks, selected with the expectation that they become high end, top six goal scoring wingers. At this point last year, Eiserman was considered a top three candidate for the draft, but a disappointing draft year saw him fall into New York’s lap at 20. We use the term disappointing loosely too, as Eiserman still managed to set a new NTDP record for goal scoring. However, scouts were disappointed in the development of other parts of his game. As Eiserman prepares for his freshman year at Boston University, that will be the focus for him. Can he improve his off puck play and become more than just a complementary goal scorer? He should become an immediate impact player for the Terriers and possesses immense potential as a dominant goal scorer.
2. William Dufour
The big power forward remains the Islanders top prospect despite a down year in production as an AHL sophomore. However, context is important. Bridgeport was one of the worst and lowest scoring teams in the AHL last year. Despite a decrease in production, Dufour was still third on the Sound Tigers in goals scored and he still showed potential as a middle six option for the Islanders. The former QMJHL and Memorial Cup MVP is a real load to handle for defenses as he drives the net, and he has a clear understanding of his role on a scoring line as someone who can clear space and play through the middle. To take that next step as an NHL player, Dufour’s skating needs to continue improving, something that he has worked hard on since being drafted in 2020. He could probably play a depth role next year for the Islanders, but it might make more sense to have him play a third year in the AHL to continue building up his confidence as an offensive leader.
3. Danny Nelson
The team’s first pick in the 2023 NHL Draft, Nelson is coming off a successful freshman year with Notre Dame. He finished near the top of the team’s scoring chart and was highly effective as a two-way player on a low scoring, defence first Fighting Irish squad. Two years ago, Nelson rose significantly up the draft rankings late in the year with a great second half and U18’s on a deep NTDP team. A big power center, he was able to prove that he had more offensive upside than previously thought with his strong offensive finish to the year. Nelson skates well for a heavy pivot and he uses that to his advantage to drive the net and to be a factor in puck pursuit. He shows strong awareness at both ends and already has some great pro-like tendencies in his game. As Nelson’s development and game continue to tick upwards, the likelihood of him becoming a solid middle six center for the Islanders becomes greater.
4. Calle Odelius
Last year was a tough season on the injury front for the team’s first pick in 2022. Odelius suffered a broken ankle at the end of the 2023 calendar year, and it was a battle to get back into the thick of things. Limited to only 10 games at the pro level in Sweden with Djurgardens, one could argue that it was a lost year of development. Signed by the Islanders, one would think that the plan is for Odelius to play in the AHL this year with Bridgeport. Odelius’ best asset remains his mobility. An intelligent two-way player, his high-end upside remains a mystery. Due to his strong skating, he has offensive upside as a puck mover, but he has yet to truly unlock that at any level. Additionally, because of his mobility and high IQ, he possesses upside in the defensive end too. Jack-of-all-trade type defenders can be a bit difficult to project and more will be known about Odelius’ upside and NHL potential once he plays in North America.
5. Matt Maggio
The 2023 Red Tilson winner from the OHL as the league’s most outstanding player, Maggio virtually came out of nowhere to dominate the CHL at that time. His first pro season in the AHL had its ups and downs. He was in and out of the lineup a few times with minor injuries and consistency was definitely lacking. However, he still finished second on Bridgeport in goals scored and he was comfortably inside the top 20 of rookie goal scorers in the league. More shifty than truly quick, Maggio’s focus this offseason will be on continuing to improve his quickness and top speed. Additionally, he’ll look to add strength to help him improve the consistency of his play on and off the puck. But the Islanders have to be happy with the flashes that Maggio showed last year; he was the best player on the ice in some AHL games. Look for him to take a big step forward next year as an AHL sophomore.
6. Jesse Pulkkinen
The massive Finnish defender was a second-round selection of the Islanders in 2024 despite being second time eligible. The draft “re-entry” was one of the most improved young players in Finland from the year prior. He jumped from playing sparingly at the Finnish U20 level to earning significant minutes at the pro level, on top of making the Finnish WJC team. Despite nearly turning 20, Pulkkinen’s game is quite raw. He is highly skilled, more than you would expect from a 6-foot-6 behemoth. There is no doubt that he possesses upside as a point producer at the NHL level. Defensively, he can play mean and put that size to use. However, the decision making at both ends can leave some to be desired. Simply put, Pulkkinen just needs to gain experience playing at the higher levels to learn to refine his approach. He’ll return to JYP of Liiga (Finnish pro) and look to further establish himself as one of the top young defencemen in Finland before making the jump to North America.
7. Alex Jefferies
Jefferies recently turned pro after four solid years at Merrimack. As a senior, he battled injuries, but still managed to lead Merrimack in goals scored for the second straight year. Jeffries is at his best in transition because of his high-end skating ability. Not only is he quick, but he’s great and confident on his edges, making him very difficult to pin down. Deadly on the counterattack, Jeffries also plays a high energy game, hunting pucks to earn touches. He uses his skating ability to be a difference maker in all three zones. As an offensive player, he’s equal parts playmaker and goalscorer, but the quick release on his wrist shot might be his best asset. Jeffries will play out this year in Bridgeport after finishing the year strong at the pro level last season. He projects as a solid middle six option for the Islanders.
8. Maxim Tsyplakov
Following a breakout season in the KHL that saw Tsyplakov score 31 goals (second on Spartak Moscow), he inked a contract with the Islanders and will compete for a top nine job in camp this season. As you may have guessed, his shot is his biggest weapon, making him a threat from the perimeter and on the powerplay. However, the big winger loves to take the puck hard to the net and uses his size to his advantage to get looks between the hash marks. The questions surrounding his game revolve around pace, as Tsyplakov is a good, but not great skater. Additionally, will his game away from the puck be up to par, or will he become more of a powerplay specialist for the Islanders? We won’t know the outcome until the season starts, however this was an excellent signing by New York. They apparently beat out several other organizations for Tsyplakov’s services and he will be given every opportunity to make an impact.
9. Kamil Bednarik
Another second-round selection of the Islanders in 2024, Bednarik is a mature, two-way pivot out of the NTDP. Billed as one of the draft’s top defensive forwards, Bednarik projects as a solid middle six player in the future. If the offensive game doesn’t continue to evolve with greater responsibility given to him compared to with the NTDP, then Bednarik probably tops out as a potential replacement for Casey Cizikas. However, Bednarik has shown flashes of skill and strong playmaking ability. He skates well and can push pace as a carrier. Heading to Boston University with fellow recent Islanders draftee Cole Eiserman, Bednarik probably starts his NCAA career as a bottom six player. It could be important to temper expectations offensively early on, however he should slowly earn more ice time and responsibility through his sophomore and junior seasons.
10. Quinn Finley
After being selected in the third round by the Islanders in 2022, Finley decided to play another year in the USHL rather than attend Wisconsin. This was a wise decision as it allowed him to add strength and build up confidence before making the big jump to the NCAA. We saw the importance of that decision this past year during his excellent freshman year for the Badgers. Not only was Finley a key secondary contributor for them, but he played a solid depth role on team USA at the WJC’s, helping them win gold. Finley has a lot of upside as a goal scorer because of his excellent puck skill and quick release. He can create his own chances through speed and skill, but he also works well as a complementary piece with his ability to find soft spots in coverage and his high-end shooting ability. Wisconsin is on an upward trend as a program again and Finley should be right at the forefront of that over the next few seasons.
11. Justin Gill
It worked for Matt Maggio, why not for Justin Gill? Both players were drafted in their final year of draft eligibility. Both players returned to the CHL for stellar overage seasons. Gill’s game is already very pro ready. He’s excellent in all situations and was one of the top defensive forwards in the QMJHL. He’s also a physical presence who plays a high energy game that is predicated on quick touches and middle lane activation. Is he the most individually skilled or creative pivot? No, and that’s why he’s probably best suited to become a solid bottom six player for the Islanders in the future. However, his speed, tenacity, and versatility give him a solid floor as a potential NHL player.
12. Cameron Berg
After two somewhat stagnant development years with the University of Nebraska Omaha, Berg hit the transfer portal and landed with North Dakota, a decision that has had a profound impact on his play and projection. Berg set new career highs in every statistical category and finished third in scoring for UND last year. The power center does his best work near the crease or in transition. His projection still remains the same as it was when he was drafted; a quality middle six forward. Yet, after a strong junior year in a new program, he seems more likely to reach that upside.
13. Isaiah George
Without a doubt, George has to be considered one of the better skating defensive prospects on the planet. His four-way movement is so fluid thanks to his crisp edgework and explosive first few strides. However, George’s offensive skill set never really developed in the OHL the way many anticipated it would. That said, George has developed well as a defensive player. What’s in store for George as a pro? That remains to be seen. A future, stable, bottom pairing defender?
14. Dmitry Gamzin
Much like Pulkkinen, the Islanders selected Gamzin this past draft outside of his first year of eligibility. Already 21, Gamzin had a breakthrough year in Russia, emerging as a quality netminder in both the KHL and the VHL (Russia’s top and second men’s leagues). The 6-foot-3 stopper will return to Russia this year and look to establish himself as a starter for CSKA.
15. Henrik Tikkanen
The massive netminder had played the last two seasons in the ECHL/AHL on a minor league deal, but his strong performance in a limited sample with Bridgeport last year helped earn him an ELC from the Islanders recently. Can he build off his breakthrough performance and give New York a goaltending prospect ready to push for a roster spot?